EU rejects Trump suggestion for quotas on EU cars

The European Union signaled it would reject any U.S. push to curb imports of EU cars and auto parts, highlighting the risk of greater transatlantic trade tensions.

EU trade chiefs meeting in Brussels dismissed an idea floated by President Donald Trump earlier this month of fixing quotas on European automotive exports to the U.S. He claimed such shipments pose a threat to national security.

On 17 May, Trump put off a decision on auto tariffs for 180 days while saying that "domestic conditions of competition must be improved by reducing imports" and instructing U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer to address the matter in talks with the EU and Japan. Voluntarily restraining exports is illegal under World Trade Organization rules.

"That is something that we are 100% against," Swedish Trade Minister Ann Linde told reporters in Brussels where she met her EU counterparts. Other national ministers and European Trade Commissioner Cecilia Malmstrom echoed the point by saying the 28-nation bloc is determined to respect WTO requirements.

Being played out in the shadow of a U.S.-China trade war that has unnerved investors worldwide, the transatlantic discord over tens of billions of dollars in European auto exports to the American market risks morphing into a new headwind for the global economy.

The issue could scuttle planned EU-U.S. negotiations on eliminating tariffs on industrial goods across the board and end a trade truce struck by both sides in July 2018. That in turn would increase the likelihood of U.S. duties on European cars and an EU tit-for-tat response.

Last year, Trump declared American imports of steel and aluminum a national-security threat and imposed levies of 25% and 10%, respectively, on shipments from around the world including the EU. That prompted the bloc to retaliate with a 25% tariff on €2.8bn ($3.1bn) of American goods including Harley-Davidson motorcycles, Levi Strauss jeans and bourbon whiskey.

A 25% U.S. levy on foreign cars would add €10,000 to the sticker price of EU vehicles imported into the country, according to the European Commission, the bloc's executive arm.

"We hope that the tariffs will not be put into practice at all," Linde said. "That is a really, really tough situation for the Swedish car industry and the European car industry. So that would be a catastrophe."

At the same time, Malmstrom said the EU has a "very firm" position against any "managed trade" arrangement that would limit European exports to the American market in return for an exemption from the threatened U.S. auto levies.

U.S. tariffs on European cars and auto parts would mark a significant escalation of transatlantic tensions because the value of EU automotive exports to the American market is about 10 times greater than that of the bloc's steel and aluminum exports combined. As a result, European retaliatory duties would target a bigger amount of U.S. exports to Europe.

The EU plans to hit as much as €20bn of U.S. goods with tariffs should Trump impose duties on European cars and auto parts, Jean-Luc Demarty, the commission's outgoing director general for trade, said in late January.

Caterpillar trucks, Xerox machines and Samsonite International luggage are among U.S. goods that would face such EU retaliation, a senior European official said in late February on the condition of anonymity.